As a seasoned restaurant chef with a decade of experience, I’ve had the opportunity to use a variety of kitchen tools and cookware. In this article, I focus on comparing two well-known Dutch ovens: the AmazonBasics and the Smithey Dutch Oven. These are favorites among both home cooks and professional chefs.
I’ll be evaluating these Dutch ovens based on several key factors to help you decide which one best meets your cooking needs. These factors include:
- Material
- Weight
- Heat retention and compatibility
- Lid fit
- Handles and product design
- Colors
- Maintenance and cleaning
- Durability and performance
- Warranty
- Price
The Smithey Dutch Oven is a culinary masterpiece crafted with meticulous attention to detail. This Dutch oven is one of my favorites, as I am captivated by its sturdiness, premium materials, and timeless design.
The AmazonBasics Dutch Oven is an affordable kitchen essential that combines classic design with modern convenience. Learn more about the features of this Dutch oven below.
You’ll discover Smithey in the exclusive TOP-5 selection of the dutch ovens.
We’ll start by taking a closer look at each Dutch oven, and then dive into their differences and advantages, to help you make an informed choice.
In this review, I provide an independent assessment of the pros and cons of Smithey and AmazonBasics, based on my experience as a chef. If you choose to purchase it, please consider using the referral links included in this article. I earn a small commission from your purchases at no additional cost to you, which helps support this blog. Thank you!
Smithey VS AmazonBasics: Material
| Smithey | AmazonBasics |
|---|---|
| Smithey Dutch Ovens are crafted from high-quality cast iron. They are hand-finished with a polished interior and a matte enameled exterior. Hence, it gives them a sleek and premium appearance. | The AmazonBasics Dutch Oven is made of high-quality cast iron. This classic material ensures even cooking and maintains heat effectively. However, I noticed a slight difference in its thickness compared to other Dutch ovens I have tested. AmazonBasics seems lighter and not as thick as other Dutch oven brands. |
Smithey VS AmazonBasics: Weight
| Smithey | AmazonBasics |
|---|---|
| Because of its high-quality construction, Smithey Dutch Ovens are known for their heft. While the material used proves its durability, it can be a drawback for some people who are not used to heavy cookware. | The AmazonBasics Dutch oven, weighing around 13 pounds, is relatively manageable to lift and move, making it suitable for home cooks. |
Smithey VS AmazonBasics: Heat Retention and Compatibility
| Smithey | AmazonBasics |
|---|---|
| The Smithey Dutch Oven excels in heat retention, making it ideal for precise temperature control during cooking. Its cast iron body retains heat exceptionally well, which is crucial for recipes like braised short ribs, where a steady simmer is needed to tenderize the meat and enhance flavors. The Dutch oven’s compatibility with various heat sources, including stovetops, ovens, and open flames, allows for a seamless transition from searing to slow braising. | The AmazonBasics Dutch Oven excels in heat retention. It can maintain a consistent cooking temperature during slow cooking. It’s compatible with a variety of stovetops, including induction. Additionally, it is also oven-safe up to 400 degrees Fahrenheit. |
Smithey VS AmazonBasics: Lid Fit
| Smithey | AmazonBasics |
|---|---|
| The Smithey Dutch Oven comes with a well-fitting lid that helps to trap moisture and heat effectively, ensuring your dishes come out perfectly cooked. It has self-basting spikes under the lid to ensure even moisture and flavor distribution, improving the taste and texture of dishes. | The AmazonBasics Dutch Oven features a snug-fitting lid to trap moisture and flavor, but some steam leakage was observed during cooking. Despite this, my dishes still turned out to be flavorful and succulent. |
Smithey VS AmazonBasics: Handles and Product Design
| Smithey | AmazonBasics |
|---|---|
| The handles of the Dutch oven are thoughtfully crafted, offering a comfortable hold and effortless control. The handles’ ergonomic design makes it easy to lift and maneuver even when carrying a heavy pot filled with food. The Dutch oven’s elegant appearance combines classic allure with modern sophistication. Smithey Dutch ovens truly serve as authentic, eye-catching centerpieces in any kitchen. | The AmazonBasics Dutch Oven has sturdy, oversized handles for easy handling, even when filled with heavy dishes. The design is classic and elegant, making it suitable for serving dishes on the dining table, though it may not match the grandeur of other well-known Dutch ovens. |
Smithey VS AmazonBasics: Colors
| Smithey | AmazonBasics |
|---|---|
| Smithey offers a limited color range. It has an enameled exterior, typically featuring a classic black finish. | The AmazonBasics Dutch Oven offers a variety of color options, including blue, gray, green, light pink, matte navy, matte white, navy, orange, purple, red, and white. |
Smithey VS AmazonBasics: Maintenance and Cleaning
| Smithey | AmazonBasics |
|---|---|
| While cast iron requires a tad more maintenance than nonstick alternatives, the Smithey Dutch Oven‘s smooth interior enamel makes cleaning a relatively straightforward task. I only need to soak it briefly and scrub it gently with a non-abrasive sponge to remove cooking residues. It’s essential to ensure thorough drying and apply a light oil coating to prevent rust to maintain its optimal condition. | The AmazonBasics Dutch Oven is not dishwasher safe, and the manufacturer recommends hand washing. It can be a little difficult to clean as it needs soaking and multiple rounds of scrubbing to remove food residue. This Dutch oven might not be the best choice if you prefer low-maintenance cleaning. |
Smithey VS AmazonBasics: Durability and Performance
| Smithey | AmazonBasics |
|---|---|
| Smithey undeniably upholds its dedication to durability, meticulously crafting this Dutch oven with top-tier materials. The Dutch oven’s remarkable performance makes it a wise long-term investment. By giving proper care and maintenance, this Dutch oven can endure for many years and become a cherished heirloom passed down to the next generation. | After continuous usage, the AmazonBasics Dutch Oven exhibits no wear and tear indications, suggesting its durability. Its kitchen performance is consistently reliable, consistently producing excellent results with dishes. |
Smithey VS AmazonBasics: Warranty
| Smithey | AmazonBasics |
|---|---|
| Smithey offers a limited lifetime warranty on their Dutch Ovens. This warranty reflects the company’s confidence in the product’s durability. | The AmazonBasics Dutch Oven offers a standard one-year warranty, which is typical. Some premium Dutch oven brands provide a lifetime warranty but often come with a higher price tag. |
Smithey VS AmazonBasics: Price
| Smithey | AmazonBasics |
|---|---|
| Smithey Dutch Ovens are on the higher end of the price spectrum, justifying the investment with premium materials and craftsmanship. | Typically, AmazonBasics Dutch Oven is more budget-friendly. Hence, it is more accessible to a broader range of consumers. |
Cooking Test
To objectively compare the capabilities of each Dutch oven, a cooking experiment was carried out. Red Wine Braised Short Ribs were prepared as the test dish. During this evaluation, three critical factors were considered: the effectiveness of browning, the ability to retain moisture, and the overall flavor of the final dish.
Browning
The Smithey Dutch Oven‘s remarkable heat retention produced a flawless sear.
Smithey made the ribs brown evenly and thoroughly, improving the dish’s overall look and flavor. The result was a visually beautiful and scrumptious base for braising.
The AmazonBasics Dutch Oven demonstrated superior browning results. The even heat distribution and snug-fitting lid allowed for precise control over browning, ensuring a beautifully caramelized exterior on our red wine-braised short Ribs.
Moisture Retention
Both Dutch ovens exhibited impressive moisture retention capabilities during the lengthy braising process. The Smithey Dutch Oven is renowned for its ability to maintain a consistent simmer. It ensured that the short ribs remained juicy and tender. The braising liquid clung to the meat, resulting in a perfectly moist final dish.
Final Flavor
Regarding the final flavor of the dishes, it was a close call. In the Smithey Dutch Oven, precise temperature control allowed the flavors to meld harmoniously. The short ribs developed a remarkable depth of flavor, their taste rich and satisfying.
The AmazonBasics Dutch Oven also delivered delectable dishes.
How We Tested
I initiated the cooking test by searing short ribs, focusing on how well each Dutch oven could brown them.
Next, I moved to the braising step, paying special attention to their moisture-retaining properties. This aspect is crucial for ensuring the meat’s tenderness and juiciness.
After the braising process, I evaluated the final taste and tenderness of the Red Wine Braised Short Ribs cooked in each Dutch oven. This assessment included examining the depth of flavors and the softness of the meat.
This culinary experiment provided insightful comparisons of the AmazonBasics and Smithey Dutch ovens’ performance.
Conclusion: Smithey is The Winner
In concluding this comprehensive comparison between the Smithey and AmazonBasics Dutch Ovens, my extensive experience as a seasoned restaurant chef has led me to a clear verdict. After evaluating each Dutch oven across various critical factors – including material, weight, heat retention and compatibility, lid fit, handles and design, color options, maintenance, durability, warranty, and price – the winner emerges unequivocally: the Smithey Dutch Oven.
The Smithey Dutch Oven distinguishes itself with exceptional craftsmanship, superior materials, and a design that combines both elegance and functionality. Its performance in the cooking test, particularly in browning and moisture retention, was outstanding. The even browning of the short ribs and the consistent simmer it maintained during the braising process were exemplary, contributing significantly to the final dish’s juiciness and flavor.
While the AmazonBasics Dutch Oven is a commendable contender, especially considering its affordability and decent performance in our tests, it falls short when pitted against the premium qualities of the Smithey. The Smithey Dutch Oven’s ability to enhance the overall taste and texture of the dishes, coupled with its robust construction and timeless design, makes it an invaluable asset in the kitchen – one that justifies its price and stands as a worthwhile investment for both home cooks and professional chefs.
Therefore, based on my rigorous analysis and hands-on experience, I confidently recommend the Smithey Dutch Oven as the superior choice for culinary enthusiasts seeking excellence in their kitchen endeavors.
However, if you are looking for an affordable Dutch oven for home cooking, then, Smithey might be a good option for you. If you decide to purchase it, please use my referral link.
Chef Bradley Thompson highly recommends to check his list of the best Dutch ovens.